ARTICLE (Part 1 of 5):
Demystifying Cost-Savings Models
©2002 Dee
McCrorey
Some
years ago I was fortunate to receive training from a
VP of Finance. His task was to bring me up to speed
on the financial aspects of my new position as a national
accounts manager. The sales force had recently signed
a lucrative contract, and I was scheduled to present
to the new client in two weeks.
The VP, whom we'll call Paul, started by placing three
Profit and Loss statements on the table.
"OK, what jumps out at you?" he said.
"The title," I responded. The look on his face indicated
that he knew his job was cut out for him.
"Dee, there's a story in the data. The trick is to discover
what the numbers are trying to tell you-the clues that
are buried within the data. It's similar to how a medical
examiner inspects a corpse. "
Paul sure knew how to create a powerful visual! The
good news is that I learned how to explain the financial
story to my clients, many of who were not comfortable
with numbers.
Many people shy away from learning about the financial
aspects of their business because they feel intimidated.
In reality, a basic financial understanding is critical
to advance your projects and career.
In the next five issues of Rt Times we'll offer you
cost-savings ideas and negotiations tips you can use
to manage your business. This month's issue begins by
helping you become more familiar with two finance models
used for capturing and tracking cost savings.
Cost savings are important because the best corporate
entrepreneurs operate their business unit like a standalone
business, which includes the ability to clearly define
and produce auditable financial results for your programs,
projects, and operations.
This becomes even more critical when quality initiatives
such as Lean Enterprise or Six Sigma become part of
the equation, given that these programs require you
to track and report quantifiable results.
Partnering With Your Finance Department
Partnering with the finance department became part of
my standard business operations. After accepting a senior
manager's position for a Fortune 500 company based in
Silicon Valley, my #1 priority within the first 30 days
was to create a budding partnership with our department's
financial analyst, John.
John and I spent two hours discussing the financial
soundness of my business. Although "-John-" had limited
knowledge of my operations, he offered suggestions on
opportunities for financial savings. I took copious
notes.
During the year that John was our financial analyst,
he became extension of my core team. I ensured he was
involved in operations reviews, quarterly supplier updates,
and that he participated in new vendor negotiations.
It wasn't a flawless partnership, but when crunch time
came for preparing our annual budget, he did excellent
job of representing my business within his team. This
was particularly important because budget discussions
and informal decisions were typically made long before
the formal budget presentations occurred.
This win-win relationship helped John's career as well.
It didn't hurt being a member of a team that captured
millions of dollars in direct (hard), indirect (soft),
and operational efficiency savings for the company.
Cost-Savings Model#1: Return
on Investment
If you're looking to capture direct (hard)
cost savings, you'll want to use the classic Return
on Investment (ROI) model. These types of savings will
directly impact a company's bottom line (Investment/Costs
= ROI).
To qualify as ROI cost savings, processes must be documented
as a measurable part of your business plan. Examples
of ROI savings would include:
- Reducing
purchases or cost of ownership. For example, if you're
planning to cut computer purchases as a means of cost
reduction, you could capture this as a hard- cost
savings. Don't forget to include any associated costs
(cost of ownership), such as technical support, training,
software, or connectivity.
-
Avoiding higher costs that otherwise would have occurred.
If you can renegotiate pricing of existing goods or
services, you can certainly capture this as direct
cost savings.
-
Improving the total value of a purchased good or service.
For example, if you signed a supplier agreement last
year that included X, Y, and Z services in the contract,
this year you can renegotiate with the supplier by
extending the reach of existing services to your internal
customers. This allows you to avoid bringing on a
new supplier.
Keep
in mind that price reductions such as those driven by
outside factors (for example, market conditions) do
not qualify as hard cost savings.
Cost-Savings
Model#2: Cost-Benefit Analysis
The
Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) finance model allows more
flexibility than straight ROI tracking. It allows you
to also track the following:
-
Indirect (soft) cost savings. You can reduce the cost
of doing business for another department because of
the streamlined process you recently implemented.
The other department reduces their administrative
overhead to one person from three, and uses the other
two individuals to manage new projects. This not only
reduces their administrative overhead (indirect),
but in this instance also allows you to capture cost
avoidance savings for the money saved by not having
to hire two contractors.
-
Cost avoidance savings. Cost avoidance occurs when
you reduce or eliminate a new cost that would have
otherwise occurred. For example, a cost avoidance
would occur if you eliminate or reduce a published
supplier price increase by aggressive bidding or savvy
negotiations. Also, you can consider negotiating volume
discounts and consolidating business from multiple
vendors to a few as cost avoidance savings.
-
Operational efficiencies. Operational efficiencies
are actions that result when less work effort is required
to achieve the same, or better, result. If you implement
a new tool that reduces the number of steps to complete
a process, and if it reduces the administrative burden
on your department, it qualifies as operational efficiency
cost savings (only if it reduces expenses that come
from regular staff salaries, temporary employment
fees, overtime, or per diem payments).
The
Big Picture
Cost savings opportunities exist not only in what we
do, but also in how we do it. It's never a good strategy
to allow the pursuit of cost savings to be the sole
determinant when selecting a product, supplier, or work
method. Remember that cost savings must be consistent
with the quality of goods and services required to keep
your business competitive for the long haul.
©Copyright
2000-2005 Risktaking for Success, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
We do not rent, sell or loan our subscriber list.
|